Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Regarding Utopia in Today's Society

There was a comment in class from a few weeks ago where the United States was observed to be a very rich, prosperous nation. In honesty, part of me cringed when I heard this said. It's not so much that I disagree with that the US is a prosperous nation. Certainly, our version of poverty is unlike that of a nation where people have trouble eating due to famine. However, I think it's important to look at our country from more pragmatic eyes.

Crime in our country, whether it's civil or criminal, is present despite the best intentions of our government. Our Congress holds an all time low of trust with the people .. due to the massive amounts of money that is swaying our representative's votes. People struggle with two, sometimes three jobs, to barely pay bills and feed their families.


That period marked a time where the value of homes plummeted, yet the value of the mortgages stayed high simply because the banks didn't want to admit fault and accept the debt by re-evaluating mortgages. Homeowner's couldn't meet the cost of the mortgage by selling their homes, and many people abandoned their property. Some stories even rose of families living out of a U-Haul.

Our nation may be 'prosperous' when you look at our GDP, but we are nowhere near prosperous when it comes to individual happiness and freedom from strife. Each of us must fight for our own survival, and no nation, regardless of the system and its origins, can prevent tragedy .. whether it results from debt, violent crime, or abuse.

No Utopian system, no matter how 'perfect' or 'prosperous' it may seem, can save each and every single individual. I am a victim of abuse, and many of my close friends are as well. Each tragedy that occurs shapes who we are and defines us on some level, and no Utopia can prevent all individuals from falling through the cracks. 

Whether it's the land of the free and the home of the brave, or a dystopia where there's no reason to think .. where ignorance is peace and freedom is slavery .. no system can fix every individual issue because (as we've found time and again) no individual perfectly conforms to the laws and ideals of a society. Is the US a prosperous country? Certainly. Is it Utopian, certainly not. 

We, as humans, will never be free from strife. Bernard in "Brave New World" was an outcast because of his height, while Helmholtz was an outcast due to his genius. No Utopian system perfectly accommodates each individual, so why bother trying? 

A bleak outlook? Maybe. But does that invalidate the point?

2 comments:

  1. I like your last sentence. I have to agree with you, again. Not everyone can agree on a specific idea, let alone how to live a perfect life. Utopia as a universal system does not work. It only is a fantasy that we can dream.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You're very right when you say that prosperity does not equal an utopia. This wasn't something I considered until now, but it makes complete sense!

    I also agree that we'll never really attain an utopia, or that we can even agree on what constitutes an utopia; however, I think there are some qualities we can agree that would make the world a better place. Even though we'll never create an utopia, that doesn't mean we shouldn't try to make our world better, right?

    ReplyDelete